At We Make It Personal, we are dedicated to helping our customers create the perfect, one-of-a-kind gift. Whether you are ordering online or at one of our locations, you are receiving personal and custom service from our creative, knowledgeable, and friendly staff.
For all other products on this website you may submit an order form and our designers will create the item for you. You can have it shipped to you, or pick it up at one of our two South Jersey locations.

You may also order items in person at any of our locations.  In most cases, customization only takes minutes.

Contact us at

 We Make It Personal
(609) 938-0208
852 Asbury Avenue
Ocean City, NJ
Joy’s Hallmark Marlton
(856) 596-6201

230 N. Maple Ave
Marlton, NJ

How much does it cost to have something engraved?

All of the engraving is included in the cost of the product. The only exception is if you want to engrave the back of an item or if you send us an image that takes us a long time to edit. In the rare case that we will charge more, before engraving, we would quote you a price.

But the front is free?

Yes! You can design and personalize whatever you want since all of our products start blank.

Are you sure?

As shore as the waves in the sea.

How long does it take to engrave an item if I come to one of your locations?

The average time to engrave is 20 minutes, but it depends on how much information is on the product. It could be as little as 30 seconds or as long as an hour.

How do you care for the cutting boards?

You may use mineral oil to extend the life of your bamboo cutting board, but it is not necessary.

To clean, we recommend hand washing the cutting board with soap
and water.

The cutting boards are NOT dishwasher safe.

How long does it take to receive a proof if I order online?

Once we receive your order, we will send a proof within 48 hours.

Can I put a logo or my own image on the product?

Yes. Email us what you would like and we will let you know if we are able to do so. If we are, we will send you a proof of the logo on the product that you want.

Can I bring in a product for you to engrave?

Unfortunately, our machines are only calibrated to engrave on products that we carry in the store.

Any other questions?

Feel free to email us at!

Get Connected

  • american express
  • apple pay
  • diners club
  • discover
  • jcb
  • master
  • shopify pay
  • visa